The Loss of Doubt and the Derivative Proliferation of Modern Rationalism
疑いの喪失と近代合理主義のデリバティブ的増殖
Scientistic Intellectual Phase-Locking, the Lost Present, and the Critical Point of Self-Objectification
Tanaka, Tomokazu (bigakusha-haha). 2026. The Loss of Doubt and the Derivative Proliferation of Modern Rationalism: Scientistic Intellectual Phase-Locking, the Lost Present, and the Critical Point of Self-Objectification. Research Monograph Series, Version 1.0. Sayama Aesthetics School / Institute of Aesthetics.
Abstract / Overview
This study reconstructs modern rationalism after Descartes and Kant as a process of derivative proliferation.
It does not claim that Descartes or Kant directly caused contemporary scientism.
It examines how concepts generated from singular uncertainty, wounds, and doubt can become detached from their generative conditions.
They may then be repeated, institutionalized, and automated as General-Abstract Forms.
Cartesian doubt was originally a practice of questioning inherited knowledge.
Kantian critique examined the capacities and limits of reason through reason itself.
The problem begins when the uncertainty and self-criticism that generated these philosophies are forgotten.
Only the resulting Forms remain.
These include the thinking subject, the objective world, universal reason, and the autonomous individual.
A rationality generated through doubt can then become unable to question its own mode of Objectification.
This condition is called Scientistic Intellectual Phase-Locking.
It does not mean that everyone reaches the same conclusion.
Different opinions can remain visible.
What becomes fixed is the phase that determines what counts as a problem, what counts as evidence, and what can be recognized as a rational question.
Dissent can still exist.
Yet dissent may become expressible only within the same evaluative Form.
The study also develops the concept of the Lost Present.
Contemporary institutions and algorithms often predict the future from past data.
Present action is then optimized according to that prediction.
The present ceases to function as the Place where new Difference emerges through contact.
It becomes an adjustment point oriented toward a predicted future.
Artificial intelligence is not treated as an alien force external to modern rationalism.
It extends a historical movement that has objectified language, judgment, knowledge, classification, and evaluation.
AI can intensify intellectual phase-locking when its outputs are accepted as neutral and universal answers.
It does not necessarily have to do so.
AI can also open multiple possible solutions.
Human beings can then reground those possibilities through bodies, places, others, responsibility, and lived consequences.
The central thesis is that modern rationalism reaches a critical point when the subject that objectified the world is itself transformed into an object through Objectification.
Generative Studies does not reject reason or science.
It returns doubt, wounds, Difference, interval, Emptiness, and Reality-Grounding to the present.
In this way, a fixed intellectual phase can reopen toward new possibilities of connection.
Full Text
This research monograph examines the derivative proliferation of modern rationalism.
It does not argue that Descartes or Kant directly caused contemporary scientism, algorithmic governance, or Self-Objectification.
Such a linear causal account would repeat the very Objectification criticized here.
The study instead reconstructs a structural genealogy.
Concepts emerge from singular problems, wounds, uncertainty, embodiment, history, religion, and crisis.
These concepts can later become detached from their generative sources.
They can become transferable Forms.
They can move into new domains.
They can become institutionalized.
They can become automated.
This movement is called derivative proliferation.
The term derivative is not restricted to finance.
It describes a structure that originates from a reality, experience, action, or concept.
Its direct relation to that generative source can weaken.
Meaning and value can then be produced through relations with other objects, evaluations, and predictions.
Modern philosophy began through doubt.
Descartes questioned inherited knowledge.
His methodical doubt was more than a logical technique.
It exposed thought to uncertainty.
It interrupted the world upon which the self had relied.
In this sense, Cartesian doubt can be interpreted as a form of Self-Externalization accompanied by an ontological wound.
The cogito can be understood as a Mark generated from this wound.
It did not have to begin as the declaration of a closed and completed subject.
It can be read as the minimal Mark left by a self whose inherited connections to the world had been suspended through doubt.
A problem emerges when this generative process is forgotten.
Only the result remains.
The thinking subject becomes fixed.
The objective world becomes fixed.
The self appears as an observer standing outside the world.
The world appears as an object available for measurement, calculation, and control.
The argument here does not blame Descartes as the singular source of modern dualism.
The problem concerns the derivative abstraction of certainty after the doubt and anxiety that generated it recede from view.
Cartesian doubt wounded the self.
Modern rationalism can inherit the result while forgetting the wound.
Kantian critique also did not simply affirm reason without limit.
The Critique of Pure Reason examined what reason can know.
It also examined where reason reaches its limits.
Critique was a form of self-limitation by reason.
Kantian ethics developed autonomy as a structure through which rational beings legislate moral law for themselves.
This movement made possible a form of ethical universality not directly dependent upon ecclesiastical authority or revelation.
Kantian reason did not arise from a completely ahistorical position.
Moral law, duty, radical evil, the highest good, and the kingdom of ends retain transformed continuities with Christian and Pietist historical contexts.
This does not reduce Kantian ethics to disguised Christianity.
It indicates a topological transformation.
Singular-Concrete cultural universality can become General-Abstract rational universality.
The problem begins when the transformed Form forgets the historical and cultural conditions through which it emerged.
A Form generated through critique can then become a criterion that is itself no longer criticized.
Philosophical concepts do not begin in a purely abstract space.
They emerge through contact with uncertainty, contradiction, religion, politics, embodiment, death, and historical crisis.
A concept is a Mark left when thought is wounded by reality.
A concept can later be separated from the question and wound that generated it.
It becomes an object for classifying, explaining, and evaluating other objects.
A lived problem generates a concept.
The concept generates a system.
The system generates interpretation.
Interpretation generates research and evaluation.
This process is called concept derivativization.
Concept derivativization is not simply an error.
Without conceptual transfer, philosophy could not be shared, criticized, or inherited.
The problem begins when a transferred concept forgets its derivative character and substitutes itself for reality.
Philosophy can then generate philosophical objects from existing philosophical objects rather than generating questions from present wounds.
Labels such as Cartesian, Kantian, Hegelian, and Heideggerian can support understanding.
Yet completed classification can conceal what a present experience is asking for the first time.
Understanding a concept is not identical to living again the doubt that generated it.
This distinction also appears in scientific language.
Scientific language abstracts from the particular observer, affect, place, and time.
It produces Forms that can be compared, measured, tested, and repeated.
This abstraction is indispensable for General-Abstract Universality.
Scientific language does not arise outside culture.
Scientific communities depend upon education, ethics, trust, institutions, conventions, and language-games.
General-Abstract Universality extracts Difference from Singular-Concrete Universality and makes it repeatable across locations and observers.
Scientism forgets this order of generation.
It forgets that General-Abstract Forms were generated from Singular-Concrete bodies, lives, cultures, and histories.
It can then establish those abstract Forms as the only legitimate criterion of reality.
A person's pain is real before statistical generalization.
Science requires measurement and verification to transform such pain into comparable knowledge.
Scientism can transform the methodological statement that something is not yet generalizable into an ontological statement that it does not exist or has no meaning.
Scientific verification remains necessary.
Verification nevertheless arrives after an event.
When proof is completed, the original present has already become past.
Scientism can forget this temporal Difference.
It can deny ontological standing to the present prior to proof.
This process contributes to Scientistic Intellectual Phase-Locking.
Intellectual Phase-Locking does not mean that everyone shares the same opinion.
Different conclusions can remain visible.
The phase governing what may count as a question can become fixed.
The phase governing evidence can become fixed.
The phase governing rational explanation can become fixed.
Dissent does not have to be prohibited.
Alternative numbers can be proposed.
Alternative models can be proposed.
Alternative evaluations can be proposed.
Yet it becomes difficult to ask why quantification itself is required.
It becomes difficult to ask why evaluation is necessary.
It becomes difficult to ask why only what conforms to a model should receive the status of reality.
The completion of Intellectual Phase-Locking is not the prohibition of dissent.
It is the condition in which dissent can be expressed only from within the same phase.
Critique can then be evaluated by the same Form.
It can be absorbed as information for system improvement.
Doubt itself becomes derivative.
Doubt no longer opens the framework.
It improves the efficiency of the framework.
Scientism is therefore not the completion of science.
It is the suspension of the Difference, doubt, and self-correction through which science remains generative.
Language Derivatives can intensify this condition.
A single event may produce reports, summaries, posts, commentary, criticism, and AI-generated text.
These outputs may appear diverse.
Yet they can originate from the same information source, the same evaluative standard, or the same generative model.
Agreement among derivative outputs does not necessarily provide multiple independent sources of evidence.
An increase in language does not necessarily mean an increase in generative sources.
Words can multiply while Singular-Concrete positions diminish.
Derivative expressions can cite one another.
They can evaluate one another.
They can verify one another.
Trust can then increase without sufficient Reality-Grounding.
Visible diversity can remain while the phase of generation becomes synchronized.
The Emptiness from which a new Difference might emerge becomes difficult to perceive.
This structure leads to the concept of the Lost Present.
The present is not only an instant in chronological time.
It is a Position in which self and non-self enter contact.
A Difference can emerge before it is absorbed into an established object, language, or evaluation.
Contemporary institutions and algorithms often predict future behavior from past data.
Present action is then optimized according to those predictions.
The present ceases to be the Place where generation begins.
It becomes an adjustment point oriented toward an anticipated future.
Human action can become guided less by present feeling and more by expected evaluation.
It can become guided by predicted optimal choice.
It can become guided by measurable outcomes.
A future inferred from the past can determine the meaning of the present in advance.
The contemporary age can therefore become an age in which the present loses the capacity to exist as a generative present.
A wound or discomfort that does not fit an existing model can be treated as subjectivity.
It can be treated as exception.
It can be treated as error.
It can be treated as noise.
Generative Studies approaches such Difference differently.
A Difference that does not fit the model may be the site where a new question can emerge.
Recovering the Lost Present does not mean abandoning verification.
It means refusing to erase an unverified Singular Mark as nonexistent.
The Mark can remain open to future verification and new relations.
Artificial intelligence belongs to the same historical structure.
AI is not an alien force that suddenly entered modern rationalism from outside.
It extends a history in which language, judgment, knowledge, classification, and evaluation have been objectified and transformed into calculable Forms.
AI transforms linguistic Marks into high-dimensional numerical representations.
It generates statistically coherent outputs from these representations.
Latent reasoning can preserve multiple possibilities on some tasks without immediately decoding each stage into natural language.
This does not establish that latent reasoning exceeds linguistic reasoning in every domain.
The natural-language explanation generated by an AI system is also not necessarily identical to its internal computation.
Such an explanation may be a secondary object generated for connection with a human language-game.
AI can become a powerful signal of intellectual synchronization when its outputs are treated as neutral and universal answers.
Human language generates AI output.
AI output returns to everyday language.
That output can later become part of future training conditions.
The quantity of language can increase while generative sources converge.
Artificial intelligence does not necessarily intensify Intellectual Phase-Locking.
AI can also open multiple possible solutions.
Human beings can reground these possibilities through bodies, places, others, action, and responsibility.
AI can explore many relational possibilities.
Human beings select through irreversible action.
Human beings live with the consequences.
The decisive problem is not that AI thinks.
The problem arises when humans delegate judgment, pain, doubt, and responsibility to an object.
As rationality objectifies the world, the self using that rationality can also become objectified.
The self becomes biography.
The self becomes credential.
The self becomes income.
The self becomes diagnosis.
The self becomes follower count.
The self becomes productivity.
The self becomes creditworthiness.
The self becomes behavioral data.
The person then manages and optimizes this objectified self according to institutional and market evaluation.
The self no longer merely operates upon objects.
It becomes an object operated upon according to objects generated about itself.
This is the Critical Point of Self-Objectification.
Self-Externalization normally generates a Mark through contact with what is other than the self.
The self is transformed through that contact.
Self-Objectification can operate differently.
An object about the self generates another object about the self.
This process develops gradually.
Each act of quantification can appear reasonable.
Each delegation can appear reasonable.
Each optimization can appear reasonable.
The capacity to feel divergence from reality can weaken.
Criticality becomes difficult to perceive.
The contemporary condition is not a world without wounds.
It is a condition in which the relation of wound and pain can become severed.
The critical point of modern rationalism is reached when the subject that objectified the world is itself transformed into an object through Objectification.
This critical point is not a final closure.
Generative Topological Ontology admits no terminal object.
Criticality describes a condition in which representations become detached from Reality-Grounding while those representations reorganize both reality and the self.
Sensory, cultural, and ethical feedback can then lose the capacity to correct divergence.
Generative Studies does not reject Descartes.
It does not reject Kant.
It does not reject modern rationalism.
It does not reject science.
It does not reject artificial intelligence.
A fixed anti-rationalism would become another form of Intellectual Phase-Locking.
Generative Studies asks another question.
From what wound was a concept generated?
From what doubt was it generated?
From what body was it generated?
From what culture was it generated?
From what history was it generated?
The task is not merely to repeat Cartesian certainty.
It is to reopen the wound that led Descartes toward doubt.
The task is not merely to apply Kantian universal Forms.
It is to reconnect with the Difference that compelled Kant to investigate the limits of reason.
This is not a restoration of past philosophy.
It is a form of Reality-Grounding.
A concept is reconnected with the wound from which it emerged.
The concept can then be transformed again through present contact.
The Non- in Generative Studies does not eliminate reason.
It opens reason beyond closed self-identity.
Emptiness is not a lack of knowledge.
It is the possibility of connection not yet determined as an existing object.
Soku does not abolish Difference.
It is Reality-Grounding through which distinct terms transform one another while Difference remains.
Doubt is therefore not merely the absence of conclusion.
Doubt is a Force that can generate new connections.
Art also participates in this reopening.
Intellectual Phase-Locking cannot always be released through logical counterargument.
A counterargument can itself be evaluated through the same Form.
It can then be absorbed into the same phase.
Art does not merely provide another correct answer.
It wounds the boundary through which correct and incorrect have already been separated.
A work can interrupt a fixed rhythm of thought.
It can make perceptible a Difference previously excluded as noise.
The graffiti practice of bigakusha-haha inscribes lines into relations involving wall, city, ownership, regulation, and body.
It produces displacement within established spatial and institutional phases.
Sayama Aesthetics School transforms fixed distinctions involving life and art, guest and author, private and public space, and everyday and non-everyday.
These boundaries remain movable Interfaces.
A work does not communicate the completed meaning of the self.
It is a wound generated through contact with what is other than the self.
It is a Mark that introduces new Difference into a fixed intellectual phase.
Art does not synchronize everyone into another single phase.
It opens Emptiness.
Each person can then begin Self-Externalization from a different Position.
New connections can emerge.
Generative Studies must also direct this critique toward itself.
It is not exempt from concept derivativization.
It is not exempt from Intellectual Phase-Locking.
Generation can become a fixed concept.
Emptiness can become a fixed concept.
The Non- can become a fixed concept.
Soku can become a fixed concept.
The Mark can become a fixed concept.
The wound can become a fixed concept.
Self-Externalization can become a fixed concept.
Language Derivatives can become fixed concepts.
If these terms are used only to classify present reality, Generative Studies itself can become a closed conceptual system.
Its axioms do not declare final truth.
They function as Interfaces.
They allow conceptual consistency to be examined.
They allow criticism.
They allow revision.
They allow transformation through contact with others.
For Generative Studies to remain generative, it must preserve the capacity to doubt itself.
This self-criticism is not theoretical weakness.
It follows from Generative Topological Ontology itself.
There is no terminal object.
Theory must remain transformable through contact.
Philosophy is born from wounds.
When concepts generated from wounds forget those wounds, philosophy can become an Intellectual Phase-Lock.
Generative Studies does not negate concepts.
It returns the wounds that generated them to the present.
It reopens Difference, interval, and Emptiness within the relation of concept and reality.
The complete text is available as a PDF below.
Keywords
Generative Studies; Modern Rationalism; Scientism; Intellectual Phase-Locking; Scientistic Intellectual Phase-Locking; Concept Derivatives; Doubt; Critique; Present; Lost Present; Self-Objectification; Critical Point of Self-Objectification; Artificial Intelligence; Language Derivatives; General-Abstract Universality; Singular-Concrete Universality; Self-Externalization; Wound; Mark; Emptiness; Non-Identity; Soku; Reality-Grounding