The Generative Theory of Two Universalities
二つの普遍性の生成論
The Asymmetrical Circulation between Singular-Concrete Universality and General-Abstract Universality through Mark, Kata, Form, Za, Seki, Position, Namelessness, and Cultural Generation
Tanaka, Tomokazu (bigakusha-haha). 2026. The Generative Theory of Two Universalities: The Asymmetrical Circulation between Singular-Concrete Universality and General-Abstract Universality through Mark, Kata, Form, Za, Seki, Position, Namelessness, and Cultural Generation. Research Monograph Series, Version 1.0. Sayama Aesthetics School / Institute of Aesthetics.
Abstract / Overview
This study reconsiders universality from the generative processes of culture rather than treating universality as an already completed general concept.
It reconstructs the sequence of Mark, Kata, Form, Za, Seki, Position, Namelessness, and Cultural Generation as a process through which universality emerges.
Singular-Concrete Universality and General-Abstract Universality are not two independent kinds of universality.
They are two generative modes through which the same universality develops and appears.
Singular-Concrete Universality emerges when an irreplaceable body, place, event, or relation opens toward what is other than itself without losing its singular Difference.
It does not mean that a singular case simply becomes an example of a general category.
Universality emerges through the capacity of singularity itself to generate relation beyond itself.
General-Abstract Universality emerges through the extraction of commonality, repeatability, comparability, and measurability from multiple singular-concrete relations.
It makes comparison, classification, calculation, prediction, institutionalization, and scientific verification possible.
This study does not reject abstraction.
The problem arises when General-Abstract Universality forgets the Singular-Concrete Universality that generated it and presents itself as absolute and complete.
Singular-Concrete Universality generatively grounds General-Abstract Universality.
General-Abstract Universality then acts back upon singular-concrete reality through institutions, science, technology, and language.
This circulation is asymmetrical.
A singular contact leaves a Mark.
The Mark becomes repeatable as Kata.
Kata appears perceptibly as Form.
Form becomes relationally organized through Za, Seki, and Position.
What has been generated is inherited beyond a particular self through Namelessness.
Cultural Universality emerges through this process.
Scientific Universality is a highly refined form of General-Abstract Universality.
It extracts measurable, reproducible, and verifiable relations from cultural generation.
Observation, naming, recording, measurement, technical transmission, reproduction of procedures, criticism, education, trust, and public disclosure are cultural practices.
Culture is therefore not merely an object investigated by science.
It is also a generative, historical, and practical basis that makes scientific practice possible.
This study clearly distinguishes science from scientism.
It does not reject scientific validity.
Its critique concerns the cultural tendency to treat Scientific Universality as absolute, placeless, disembodied, and ahistorical.
The validity of a scientific claim and the generative conditions that make science possible belong to different analytical levels.
Philosophy and metaphysics are not treated as immature forms of knowledge prior to science.
They are reflective cultural practices that examine conditions tacitly presupposed by scientific inquiry.
These include being, objecthood, identity, causality, time, space, truth, and intelligibility.
The study also examines Road and Kugai as a localized topological model for the generation of universality.
Road differentiates this side and the other side while also enabling contact, passage, and transformation.
Road belongs exclusively to neither side.
This dual structure discloses a Kugai structure.
Historical Kugai and the ontological structure of Road remain distinct.
Sayamaike, Gyoki, routes toward Mount Koya, mountain religious practices, Nyonin Koya, and the Sayama Aesthetics School are examined as singular-concrete historical and place-based cases.
These cases are not treated as expressions of an immutable Japanese essence.
Japanese Singular-Concrete Universality is not proposed as another absolute opposed to Western General-Abstract Universality.
It functions as a conceptual resource for disclosing the generative multiplicity of universality obscured by modern scientism.
Universality is therefore not an identity produced through the removal of singular Difference.
It is a multiple generative process through which different singularities become relational without becoming identical.
Universality is one and multiple at the same time.
Its structure remains generatively non-closed.
It continues to open connectability among different singularities.
Full Text
This research monograph reconsiders universality as a generative process rather than as a completed general concept.
Singular-Concrete Universality and General-Abstract Universality are not two independent forms of universality.
They are two generative modes of the same universality.
Singular-Concrete Universality emerges when an irreplaceable existence opens toward what is other than itself without losing its singularity.
A death cannot be exchanged for another death.
A pain cannot be fully transferred to another person.
A work emerges through a singular maker, material, place, history, and act.
A memory of a place cannot be reproduced as an identical experience.
Yet these singular realities can open relations beyond themselves.
Universality emerges through this opening.
It does not require the removal of singularity.
Singularity itself can become generative of relation.
General-Abstract Universality emerges through the extraction of common structures, rules, properties, and repeatable relations from multiple singular cases.
It makes comparison possible.
It makes classification possible.
It makes calculation possible.
It makes prediction possible.
It makes institutionalization possible.
It makes scientific verification possible.
Abstraction itself is not rejected.
The problem emerges when General-Abstract Universality forgets the Singular-Concrete Universality that generated it.
An abstraction can then present itself as a complete standard prior to singular reality.
This reversal produces a closure of universality.
Singular-Concrete Universality generatively grounds General-Abstract Universality.
General-Abstract Universality then acts back upon singular-concrete reality through institutions, science, technology, and language.
This circulation is not symmetrical.
This study calls it Asymmetrical Circulation.
Cultural generation can also be understood through this structure.
Contact involving self and what is other than self leaves a Difference in reality.
That Difference is a Mark.
A Mark can become repeatable across other bodies, places, materials, and times.
That repeatable relational structure is Kata.
Kata becomes perceptible as Form.
Form enters relations within Za.
Za is a relational field in which multiple singular existences generate relations while retaining Difference.
Seki is the irreplaceable position occupied by a singular existence within Za.
Position indicates the differential function, intensity, authority, and responsibility generated through relations involving different Seki.
What has been generated does not remain enclosed within one self.
It can be inherited by others and later generations.
Namelessness names this mode of being.
Namelessness is not anonymity.
It does not erase the maker.
It preserves provenance and responsibility while releasing generation from exclusive ownership by one self.
Workhood is closely connected to this structure.
Workhood is the mode of being through which a generated Form exceeds the maker's intention, function, ownership, and present context.
A work does not close when production ends.
Completion releases the work from direct production by the maker and opens another phase of generation.
This movement concerns Self-Posteriority.
Self-Precedence indicates that relations involving body, language, others, environment, history, and materiality are already operating before a completed self becomes constituted.
Pre-Humanity indicates that the world and its relations generate themselves prior to human naming, classification, institutionalization, and meaning.
Self-Posteriority indicates that Marks, Kata, Forms, words, works, and relations left by a self can continue beyond the intention, absence, and death of that self.
Human-Posteriority indicates that institutions, technologies, artifacts, and environmental transformations generated through human activity can continue beyond the intention and lifetime of individual human beings and potentially beyond humanity itself.
Cultural Generation takes place through the temporal Interface in which these structures overlap.
Hi is not simple logical negation.
Hi opens being beyond self-identity.
It makes differentiation involving self and what is other than self possible.
Soku does not erase Difference.
Soku opens a direct generative relation in which different beings remain different while generating relations.
Hi opens Difference.
Soku opens connection across Difference.
Generation requires the overlapping operation of these structures.
This structure also grounds Singular-Concrete Universality.
Scientific Universality is a highly refined form of General-Abstract Universality.
Science develops verifiable relations through observation.
It develops them through measurement.
It develops them through experiment.
It develops them through reproducibility.
It develops them through refutation.
It develops them through formalization.
It develops them through public verification.
This power is not rejected.
Scientific Universality has made knowledge communicable beyond personal authority and singular impression.
Yet science did not emerge outside culture.
Naming is a cultural practice.
Recording is a cultural practice.
The construction of instruments is a cultural practice.
The repetition of procedures is a cultural practice.
Education is a cultural practice.
Trust in prior records is a cultural practice.
Public criticism is a cultural practice.
Reproducibility presupposes Kata.
Objectivity presupposes verification from multiple Seki.
The public character of knowledge presupposes Za, Position, and Namelessness.
Culture is therefore not merely an object investigated by science.
It is also a generative, historical, and practical basis through which scientific practice becomes possible.
This study distinguishes science from scientism.
Science is a practice that refines relations into forms open to verification.
Scientism is a cultural position that treats scientific formalization as the exclusive legitimate form of knowledge.
Scientism extends the effective scope of Scientific Universality to Being as a whole.
It can then identify scientific description with reality itself.
The critique developed here is not directed against science.
It concerns the self-absolutization of General-Abstract Universality.
Scientific validity and the generative conditions of scientific practice must remain analytically distinct.
The cultural origin of science does not determine whether an individual scientific claim is valid.
Scientific claims must still be examined through evidence, method, logical consistency, reproducibility, explanatory power, and openness to refutation.
Philosophy and metaphysics remain relevant because science operates through presuppositions concerning being, objecthood, identity, causality, time, space, truth, and intelligibility.
Even a rejection of metaphysics can continue to depend upon implicit metaphysical assumptions.
The study also examines Road and Kugai as a topological model for Singular-Concrete Universality.
Road does not merely connect two already completed sides.
The emergence of Road also differentiates this side and the other side.
Road therefore generates separation.
At the same time, it enables connection.
Road belongs exclusively to neither side.
This structure can be described as a Kugai structure.
Historical Kugai must remain distinct from this ontological use.
Historical structures of muen, Kugai, and raku involve specific institutions, power relations, mobility, autonomy, and exclusion.
The ontological argument does not replace those historical meanings.
It examines the capacity of Road to cross fixed affiliations and generate relations involving different singularities.
Sayamaike is one singular-concrete site through which this theory has been generated.
The activities of Gyoki are another.
Routes toward Mount Koya are another.
Mountain religious practices and Nyonin Koya also contribute to the inquiry.
The Sayama Aesthetics School is likewise treated as a singular-concrete site of generation.
These are not examples added after the construction of a general theory.
They are part of the reality-grounding from which the theory emerged.
Japanese Singular-Concrete Universality does not designate an immutable essence of Japanese culture.
It does not establish a fixed opposition of Japan and the West.
Western thought also contains philosophical, artistic, religious, and practical traditions that emphasize singularity, concreteness, and relation.
Japanese culture also contains abstraction, institutionalization, exclusion, and imposed norms.
The issue concerns historical tendencies and modes of generation.
Kata, Za, Seki, Position, Ma, Road, Kugai, and Namelessness function as conceptual resources for generating relation without eliminating singular Difference.
They are not proposed as a new absolute.
They open another path for thinking universality.
Universality is not the smallest common element remaining after Difference has been removed.
Universality is the event through which different singularities become relational without being reduced to one another.
Universality is therefore one and multiple.
Singular-Concrete Universality generates General-Abstract Universality.
General-Abstract Universality acts back upon singular-concrete reality.
That return generates new singular realities.
The circulation continues.
Universality is therefore not a final closure.
It is a generatively non-closed structure through which different singularities remain capable of opening new connectability.
The complete text is available as a PDF below.
Keywords
Generative Studies; Generative Topological Ontology; Singular-Concrete Universality; General-Abstract Universality; Cultural Universality; Scientific Universality; Mark; Kata; Form; Za; Seki; Position; Namelessness; Workhood; Self-Externalization; Self-Precedence; Pre-Humanity; Self-Posteriority; Human-Posteriority; Soku; Hi; Iroke; Kugai; Road; reality-grounding; Asymmetrical Circulation; Scientism; Cultural Generation