The Generative Theory of Contradictory Co-Being and the Parallel Structure of Reality
矛盾の共存在と並列的現実の生成論
Topological Metamorphosis through Discreteness, Dispersion, Neoteny, Objectification, Mandala, and Ajikan
Tanaka, Tomokazu (bigakusha-haha). 2026. The Generative Theory of Contradictory Co-Being and the Parallel Structure of Reality: Topological Metamorphosis through Discreteness, Dispersion, Neoteny, Objectification, Mandala, and Ajikan. Research Monograph Series, Version 1.0. Sayama Aesthetics School / Institute of Aesthetics.
Abstract / Overview
This study formulates the structure of Contradictory Co-Being within Generative Studies and Generative Topological Ontology.
It examines the fact that realities that cannot be reconciled within one formal framework can nevertheless remain adjacent, parallel, and mutually effective within the same present.
Modern cognition has produced powerful forms of knowledge by identifying objects, serializing causation, and resolving contradiction.
This remains indispensable.
Reality, however, is not exhausted by serial structure.
Self and non-self can act within the same present.
Necessity and contingency can act within the same present.
Love and hatred can act within the same present.
Life and death can act within the same present.
Form and meaning can act within the same present.
Locality and totality can act within the same present.
These relations do not necessarily converge into one final solution.
The study distinguishes seriality from parallelity.
Thought predominantly organizes Difference into sequences of cause, meaning, explanation, and action.
Sensibility predominantly receives multiple effects before they have been organized into one sequence.
This distinction is not treated as a fixed dualism.
Thought can operate in parallel.
Sensibility can also become serialized.
The proposition of thinking while sensing and sensing while thinking names a generative cognition in which sensibility and thought remain different while transforming one another.
The study also distinguishes Discreteness from Dispersion.
Discreteness describes differences that remain separated while sharing one coordinate system, rule, problem setting, and scale of comparison.
Dispersion describes plural realities whose bodies, scales, temporalities, causalities, values, and conditions cannot be completely contained within one final coordinate system.
Discreteness offers multiple candidates within a shared problem.
Dispersion includes plural phases of what the problem itself is.
This distinction reveals a central problem of contemporary diversity.
Many visible differences can be arranged on one platform.
They can be evaluated through the same money, law, language, metric, or institutional procedure.
In such a case, diversity increases while different realities are translated into Discreteness within one topology.
Co-Being requires more than the multiplication of options.
It requires dispersed plurality in which heterogeneous phases remain connected without becoming reducible to one another.
Science, law, mathematics, political correctness, and global norms can provide important conditions for Co-Being.
They are not rejected.
The problem begins when General-Abstract Universality becomes the sole criterion of reality.
Singular-Concrete bodies, places, histories, silences, and untranslatable remainders can then be forced onto one evaluative plane.
An Interface with reality may become a fetish treated as reality itself.
Objectification is also interpreted as world-generation.
A human being gives an outline to part of continuous reality and identifies it as something.
The outline does not generate only an object.
It organizes the background.
It determines the Position of the viewing subject.
It configures possible actions.
It reorganizes time.
When a fallen branch is perceived as a stick or tool, the material branch changes very little.
Its relational phase changes.
The body becomes a grasper.
The surrounding world becomes a field for striking, digging, or reaching.
A change in one locality can therefore reorganize an entire world coherent with that locality.
This is topological metamorphosis.
The study refers to neoteny only in a limited and non-deterministic sense.
Neoteny is not presented as the biological cause of symbolic cognition, tools, or art.
It is considered as one condition supporting developmental plasticity and prolonged underdetermination.
A form may therefore sustain more than one possible meaning or function without immediately closing into one identity.
Tools and art are compared as different realizations of this generative capacity.
A tool connects Form with bodily efficacy.
Art connects Form with invisible, nonlocal, memorial, future, and relational dimensions.
Lascaux is not treated as the origin of art.
It is considered as a mature case in which wall, body, animal, memory, darkness, light, sound, and an invisible world can coexist at an Interface.
Mandala and Ajikan are likewise approached through comparative philosophy rather than doctrinal reduction.
A mandala does not have to be interpreted as an idol that encloses the whole within a local image.
It can function as an embodied Interface through which a differentiated whole becomes present from a locality.
Ajikan also brings Form, sound, breath, body, consciousness, and world into one present.
Self and object do not disappear into identity.
The boundary that fixes them as independent substances becomes mobile.
The central thesis is that knowledge is not exhausted by the elimination of contradiction.
Logical contradiction within one formal system should be resolved.
Topological contradiction among irreducible phases must instead be borne without severing relation.
Generative knowledge is an Interface that bears the Force of contradiction and transforms the topology of the knowing self.
Co-Being is therefore not the peaceful juxtaposition of completed entities.
It is a generative present in which different phases remain related, retain contradiction, and transform one another's possibilities of existence.
Full Text
This research monograph develops a theory of Contradictory Co-Being and the Parallel Structure of Reality.
It does not reject the law of non-contradiction.
Formal reasoning requires the distinction involving truth and falsity.
A proposition and its negation cannot both be accepted under identical conditions and in the same sense.
The contradiction examined here is different.
Lived reality contains tensions generated by different bodies, histories, relations, and temporalities acting within the same present.
An event can be experienced as liberation by one person and violence by another.
A person can love and hate the same person.
Awareness of death can intensify the desire to live.
Formal logic can distinguish the conditions involved.
Yet before such clarification, several phases already act upon one body and one place.
Contradiction therefore names a generative tension.
Plural realities cannot be reduced to one phase.
They retain incompatible demands.
They cannot eliminate one another.
They also cannot be completely severed.
Difference then becomes Force.
Within Generative Topological Ontology, Being is not an isolated substance.
Being is connectability.
Relation precedes substance.
Contradiction is therefore not merely an accident involving two completed entities.
Contact among irreducible terms belongs to existential generation.
Co-Being does not dissolve this contact into harmony.
It generates a present in which differentiated relation can persist.
Reality is serial.
Events have duration.
Actions have order.
Past results become present conditions.
A body cannot perform infinitely many actions at once.
Choice limits possibilities.
Causality, argument, procedure, memory, and responsibility depend upon seriality.
Reality is also parallel.
Multiple bodies act within the same present.
Multiple senses act within the same present.
Places, memories, institutions, forms of life, traces of the dead, and anticipations of the future also act within it.
They do not proceed at the same speed.
They do not belong to one causal sequence.
They are not completely grasped from one center.
Yet they modify one another's conditions.
Thought tends to select differences from this excessive parallelity.
It orders them.
It forms sequences of cause and meaning.
Sensibility tends to receive several effects before they are organized into one sequence.
This is not a fixed dualism.
Thought can hold several structures together.
Affect can be serialized into habitual narratives.
Serial and parallel therefore describe tendencies of connection.
Serialization remains necessary.
It makes understanding possible.
It makes transmission possible.
It makes action possible.
Closure begins when a serialized explanation is mistaken for reality as a whole.
Cause and effect can become the only permitted sequence.
Attribute and evaluation can become the only permitted sequence.
Violation and punishment can become the only permitted sequence.
Input and output can become the only permitted sequence.
What does not enter these sequences then appears as noise.
Others appear as noise.
Contingency appears as noise.
Embodiment appears as noise.
Silence appears as noise.
Place appears as noise.
Untranslatability appears as noise.
The problem is therefore not Seriality itself.
The problem is its absolutization.
This study distinguishes Discreteness from Dispersion.
Discreteness describes separated elements that share one coordinate system.
They share rules.
They share a problem setting.
They share a scale of comparison.
Distance remains measurable within the same system.
Classification is possible.
Selection is possible.
Optimization is possible.
Solutions are possible in principle.
Dispersion describes a different condition.
Different realities belong to different bodies.
They belong to different scales.
They belong to different temporalities.
They belong to different causalities.
They belong to different values and conditions of reality.
No final coordinate system completely contains them all.
Translation remains possible.
Judgment remains possible.
Yet translation leaves a remainder.
Judgment remains situated.
To say that Dispersion has no final answer does not mean that nothing can be decided.
It means that no single terminal solution can complete every phase at once.
Discreteness presents several candidates for a shared problem.
Dispersion includes several phases of what the problem itself is.
This distinction changes the meaning of diversity.
Many options can appear on one platform.
They can be evaluated through the same money.
They can be classified through the same law.
They can be expressed through the same language.
They can be ranked through the same metric.
Such a system may contain abundant visible difference.
It can nevertheless remain Discreteness within one topology.
Dispersed Co-Being is different.
Different lands, bodies, memories, religions, and forms of life remain incompletely exchangeable.
They enter relation without ceasing to differ.
Generative knowledge must therefore do more than remove contradiction.
It does not leave contradiction permanently unresolved.
It does not suspend judgments involving truth and falsity.
It describes the phase from which each term arises.
It describes the body involved.
It describes the history involved.
It examines the Forces exerted among the terms.
It then provisionally transforms their relation into a new Form, concept, institution, or action.
A solution is not a terminus.
It is a local stability open to revision.
It is an osamari.
Thinking while sensing and sensing while thinking becomes decisive.
Sensibility is not simply raw material for thought.
Affect is not merely added after a completed conclusion.
Sensing changes what counts as a problem.
Thinking changes what can be sensed.
The two generate one another.
Sensibility and thought do not become identical.
Sensibility preserves a remainder irreducible to concepts.
Thought articulates sensation into transmissible Forms.
Because Difference remains, knowledge stays open to reality.
Knowledge is not a system from which contradiction has disappeared.
It is an Interface that bears the Force of contradiction and transforms the phase of the knowing self.
Objectification must also be understood as world-generation.
Human beings draw an outline around part of continuous reality.
Something becomes identified as an object.
The Form receives a name.
It receives a function.
It receives a value.
It receives a causal Position.
The outline does more than produce an object.
Everything outside it becomes background.
The Position of the viewing subject is organized.
Possible actions are organized.
Time is reorganized.
A fallen object in a forest can be understood as a branch.
It then belongs to tree, ground, decay, and seasonal circulation.
The same object can be perceived as a stick.
The body becomes a grasper.
The environment becomes a field for striking, digging, and reaching.
A change in one locality reorganizes a whole world coherent with that locality.
Objectification is therefore not a passive copy of an external world.
It generates object, self, background, action, and time together.
Fixing an object also fixes the phase coherent with it.
An Intellectual Phase Lock occurs when a locally effective outline is mistaken for the terminal boundary of the world.
Localization itself is not rejected.
A body always connects to the world from a locality.
The problem begins when a locality is severed from the relations that generated it and made to exhaust the whole.
Generative localization creates a focus for connection.
Local fixation closes that focus as reality itself.
This issue also concerns two Universalities.
General-Abstract Universality extracts commonality from plural particulars.
It produces Forms applicable across bodies and places.
Scientific laws belong to this movement.
Legal principles belong to this movement.
Mathematical Forms belong to this movement.
Public norms belong to this movement.
These Forms can criticize local violence and arbitrary authority.
Singular-Concrete Universality emerges differently.
A singular body leaves a Mark.
That Mark can open a possibility for another body.
The original contact remains non-exchangeable.
Yet a possibility is transmitted beyond the self.
The two Universalities are not mutually exclusive.
General abstraction cannot begin without Singular-Concrete traces.
Singular experience also requires transmissible Forms if it is to be compared, tested, and inherited across distance.
The problem begins when abstraction forgets the traces that generated it.
It then returns to govern singular realities in one direction.
Scientific Universality is not invalid because it has cultural grounds.
Evidence matters.
Reproducibility matters.
Falsifiability matters.
Public criticism matters.
Science can exceed local prejudice through these practices.
Yet instruments that produce data are culturally generated.
Forms of reproducibility are culturally generated.
Ethics supporting criticism are culturally generated.
Institutions in which researchers occupy Positions are culturally generated.
Scientism is not scientific rigor.
It is the forgetting of these generative conditions.
It elevates General-Abstract Universality into the sole criterion of reality.
A similar problem can appear within law, political correctness, international norms, and global platforms.
These systems can protect those silenced within closed communities.
They can create minimum conditions for Co-Being.
A return that identifies the local as good and the universal as evil is therefore untenable.
The critical problem appears when norms created to protect Co-Being become the only legitimate vocabulary and procedure.
Classification can precede contact.
Evaluation can follow classification.
Punishment can follow evaluation.
A serial chain can replace the time required to transform a contradictory relation.
Global connection has the same ambiguity.
It can expand encounters among different phases.
It can also circulate only those differences translatable into money, English, law, metrics, and platforms.
The world can appear more diverse while Discreteness within one phase continues to proliferate.
Dispersed Co-Being requires more than visible diversity.
Untranslatable remainders must remain active within relation.
Fetish can also be understood through localization.
Localization makes attention possible.
It makes desire possible.
It makes memory possible.
It makes sacredness possible.
It makes Workhood possible.
Iroke also appears when an indeterminate future and the possibility of another's participation become localized in a Form.
Intensity becoming localized is not itself the problem.
Fetishism begins when the relations that generated the intensity are forgotten.
The Form is then treated as if it possesses Force by itself.
Price can become value itself.
Number can become reality itself.
Correct terminology can become justice itself.
An image can become the sacred itself.
The Interface then becomes an idol.
When a locality preserves its outside and leaves an Empty Seat within Form, another structure becomes possible.
The locality opens toward the world.
Workhood is not closure through completion.
It is the intensity through which a Form becomes Reality-Grounded while inviting the non-self.
Iroke is not the power of a locality to possess the whole.
It is the Force through which unrealized relations can be sensed from a locality.
Neoteny is treated cautiously.
The study does not claim that neoteny directly caused human symbolic thought, tools, or art.
It uses developmental openness as a possible condition of plasticity and semantic underdetermination.
The decisive issue is not childishness.
It is the capacity not to fix the coupling of Form and meaning too early.
In play, a branch can remain a real branch while becoming a sword, staff, animal, boundary, or tool.
This is not failure to distinguish reality from fiction.
It is the capacity to sustain material actuality and fictive function as different phases.
Maturity can therefore be redefined.
Maturity is not completion through the elimination of ambiguity.
It is the capacity to sense several possibilities, enact one of them, and remain open to further topological metamorphosis afterward.
A fallen branch becoming a tool makes this structure visible.
The material branch changes very little.
Its relation to the body changes.
Its functional phase changes.
The branch remains a branch while becoming what it previously was not.
This is not the simple destruction of identity.
Different predicates operate under different conditions.
The important generative event is that one thing bears several phases at once.
A change in relation reorganizes both self and environment.
This is topological metamorphosis.
The same principle applies to the self.
A self can preserve the same body and history while becoming another self through contact with others, places, and works.
Generation does not erase earlier identity and replace it.
Irreducible Difference enters identity and transforms the whole field of connectability.
Tools and art diverge from this capacity.
Tools connect Form to bodily efficacy.
Art connects Form to invisible relations, memory, futurity, the dead, others, and nonlocal relations.
The two can overlap in practice.
Lascaux is not treated as the first emergence of art.
Its imagery is not reduced to one theory involving hunting magic, religion, instruction, or record.
Its importance here lies in the Interface involving wall, darkness, moving bodies, light, sound, animal images, and memory.
The wall remains a wall.
The image is not the animal itself.
Yet material surface, absent animal, present body, and another temporality act within the same place.
Art can therefore be understood as an Interface generating the Co-Being of plural phases.
Mandala also presents a whole that does not erase Difference.
Differentiated Forms and activities remain differentiated.
The whole is not a superior One that homogenizes every locality.
Each locality manifests the whole through relations with other localities.
A locality is not an exchangeable fragment.
It is a Phase or Position at which the whole becomes present.
Mandala can therefore be interpreted as placing heterogeneous phases within one practical configuration while preserving Difference.
Ajikan develops the same problem through embodied practice.
The syllable A is a highly localized Form.
Yet the cosmos is not stored inside it.
Form, sound, breath, body, consciousness, moon disc, surrounding space, and world act within one present.
Self and object do not disappear into identity.
The boundary that fixed them as independent substances becomes mobile.
A non-closed whole becomes present through connection.
This can be described through Soku.
Self Soku world does not mean that self and world become one thing.
Different terms become present within the same event.
Mediating distance changes.
Difference remains.
Objectification is not abolished.
Its fixed topology is reopened toward connection.
The argument can therefore be summarized through several principles.
Reality persists serially while generating in parallel.
Seriality makes inheritance, causality, responsibility, and action possible.
Parallelity makes contact among heterogeneous phases, contingency, emergence, and Co-Being possible.
Logical contradiction under identical conditions should be resolved.
Topological contradiction involving irreducible phases must be borne without severing relation.
Discreteness is Difference within a common topology.
Dispersion is the Co-Being of plural topologies.
Sensibility tends to receive several effects in parallel.
Thought tends to articulate them serially.
Generative knowledge is not their harmonious synthesis.
It is an asymmetrical circulation through which sensing and thinking transform one another.
Objectification identifies a locality while generating a self and world coherent with it.
Intellectual Phase Lock begins when a locally effective outline is mistaken for the final boundary of the world.
Fetish is the localization of Force.
Fetishism is the forgetting of the relations that generated that Force.
When a locality preserves an Empty Seat for its outside, it can become an Interface with Workhood and Iroke.
When it exhaustively represents the whole, it becomes an idol.
The generative significance of neoteny lies in plasticity that does not fully determine meaning and function.
Maturity preserves plural possibilities while acting upon one.
It remains open to topological metamorphosis after action.
Tools and art diverge from the capacity to transform relational Phase while preserving material identity.
Mandala and Ajikan can be interpreted as Interfaces through which a differentiated whole becomes present from a locality.
Co-Being is not the peaceful juxtaposition of completed entities.
It is a generative present in which different phases sustain relation, preserve contradiction, and transform one another's possibilities of existence.
This structure is also present within the contemporary artistic practice of bigakusha-haha.
Web Installation treats the screen not as a closed surface of representation.
It becomes an Interface generating boundaries involving there and here, distance and body, sign and Reality-Grounding.
Sayama Aesthetics School does not exhibit life as a completed work.
Guests, neighborhood, building, plants, labor, memory, and online environments temporarily encounter one another.
The phases of self and place are transformed through those encounters.
Inverse Problem Art does not derive Form from predetermined content.
It first designs an outline or conditions of connection.
Unpredictable content can then emerge within those conditions.
The outline is not a boundary fixing an object.
It is a provisional Za in which heterogeneous phases can encounter one another.
Art does not restore a lost sensibility.
Generation is irreversible.
Premodern community cannot simply be recovered.
Religious totality cannot simply be recovered.
Art generates a new sensibility within present signs, institutions, technologies, and bodies.
This sensibility can reconnect with the non-self.
It opens a Seki in which sensing and thinking, locality and totality, Seriality and Parallelity, self and other can act upon the same present without erasing Difference.
The Force of reality does not lie only in resolving contradiction.
Irreducible phases can sustain differentiated relation.
Through contact, they can generate a third Phase that did not previously exist.
General-Abstract Forms remain necessary.
Yet when language, law, logic, mathematics, or norms forget that they are Interfaces with reality, they can become worshipped as reality itself.
General-Abstract Universality then becomes the ultimate fetish.
Generative knowledge thinks while sensing and senses while thinking.
It does not fuse sensibility and reason.
It preserves their Difference and bears their mutual transformation.
The whole of Co-Being is not a completed totality in which everything becomes one.
It is a non-closed whole in which what cannot become one nevertheless participates in generating the same reality.
The complete text is available as a PDF below.
Keywords
Generative Studies; Generative Topological Ontology; Co-Being; Contradiction; Contradictory Co-Being; Parallelity; Seriality; Discreteness; Dispersion; Generative Knowledge; Neoteny; Underdetermination; Objectification; Outline; World-Generation; Intellectual Phase Lock; Sensory Phase Lock; Topological Metamorphosis; General-Abstract Universality; Singular-Concrete Universality; Fetish; Idol; Iroke; Workhood; Mandala; Ajikan; Soku; Za; Seki; Position; Reality-Grounding; Inverse Problem Art; Interface Art