Research Monograph

The Generative Theory of Co-Being

共存在の生成論

Existence as the Vertical Axis, Co-Sensibility as the Horizontal Axis, and the Lost Present

Author
bigakusha-haha / Tomokazu Tanaka
Year
2026
Version
1.0
Status
Ongoing Research
Type
Research Monograph
Last Updated
July 2026
Affiliation
Sayama Aesthetics School / Institute of Aesthetics
Suggested Citation

Tanaka, Tomokazu (bigakusha-haha). 2026. The Generative Theory of Co-Being: Existence as the Vertical Axis, Co-Sensibility as the Horizontal Axis, and the Lost Present. Research Monograph Series, Version 1.0. Sayama Aesthetics School / Institute of Aesthetics.

Abstract / Overview

This study reconstructs Existence and Co-Being as two intersecting movements within Generative Studies.

Existence forms a vertical axis.

It concerns the movement through which a self questions its ground and possibility across past, present, and future.

Co-Being forms a horizontal axis.

It concerns the way a self is affected by others, nature, things, places, the dead, and unrealized futures.

The study distinguishes Son, Zai, and Kyo as operative philosophical terms.

Son names persistence and inheritance through time.

Zai names concrete presence and Position here and now.

Kyo names relational sharing without the erasure of Difference.

Zai is not a fixed point where two axes meet.

It is a topological Interface generated anew through changing relations.

The study also distinguishes coexistence from Co-Being.

Coexistence can describe already constituted beings occupying one environment.

Co-Being is more fundamental.

Relation is treated as a condition of existence rather than as something added after an individual is complete.

A self does not first exist alone and later enter relation.

The self emerges through relations with others, nature, language, culture, and place.

This account follows the relational priority of Generative Topological Ontology.

Existence is therefore not a closed substance.

It is an open topology of connectability.

Contemporary society provides increasing amounts of information about distant events and other people.

Yet knowing about an event is not identical with being-with that event.

Images, explanations, and judgments do not by themselves establish Co-Being.

Co-Being occurs when the existence of what cannot be fully assimilated by the self is nevertheless able to alter the present.

The study calls the erosion of this condition the loss of the co-existential present.

It also redefines Co-Sensibility.

Co-Sensibility is distinct from neurological synesthesia.

It is the capacity through which vision, hearing, touch, memory, affect, and thought remain mutually open.

Through this openness, a self can sense that it shares a present with what is other than itself.

Sensory Phase Lock arises when existence that does not fit an established form of recognition can no longer be sensed.

Intellectual Phase Lock and Sensory Phase Lock reinforce one another.

What cannot be sensed may fail to become an object of thought.

What cannot be thought may be excluded from sensibility as if it were unreal.

The boundary of recognizability can then be mistaken for the boundary of reality.

The study distinguishes science from scientism.

Science provides indispensable methods for testing claims.

Scientism arises when a limited method becomes the only criterion of reality.

Relations involving distance, singularity, opacity, memory, the dead, futurity, and the Force of place can then become invisible.

Generative Studies does not describe such relations as supernatural causes.

It understands them as nonlocal modes of existential generation mediated through meaning, memory, anticipation, Form, and Interface.

Lascaux cave imagery, ecclesiastical space, ritual, prayer, graffiti, Web Installation, and Sayama Aesthetics School belong to different historical contexts.

They are not reduced to one origin or purpose.

They can nevertheless be compared as Interfaces through which here connects with elsewhere, now with other times, the visible with the invisible, and the comprehensible with the incomprehensible.

Art does not make the invisible completely visible.

It does not eliminate incomprehensibility.

It opens a Seki through which what remains invisible or incomprehensible can still act upon the present.

The co-existential present can therefore be understood through Soku, Za, Seki, and Position.

Soku connects different terms without abolishing Difference.

Za opens a relational field.

Seki provides singular-concrete receptivity within that field.

Position is generated provisionally where vertical and horizontal relations become Reality-Grounded.

Namelessness describes the inheritance of existential generation beyond personal attribution.

Workhood describes the capacity of a work to continue generating relations beyond the intention and ownership of its maker.

A work leaves a Seki at which another existence can arrive and respond differently.

As long as this Seki remains open, the work functions as a co-existential Interface.

The contemporary crisis of existence is therefore not simply a failure of self-reflection.

A person may possess extensive information about the self while losing the feeling that the self is real.

The self cannot verify itself through itself alone.

The feeling of existing emerges through being touched by what is other, responding to it, and sensing one's Position change within a world.

Art therefore does not regenerate an isolated self.

It regenerates a present in which self and what is other than self can exist together.

Full Text

This research monograph develops a Generative Theory of Co-Being.

The terms Son, Zai, and Kyo are used as operative philosophical distinctions within Generative Studies.

They are not presented as claims about historical etymology.

The aim is to describe how existence is generated through relation.

Nonlocality is also used in an ontological and aesthetic sense.

It is not a direct application of quantum nonlocality to human culture.

A relation is nonlocal when its meaning and efficacy are not completed by immediate physical location.

It can be generated through distant places, other times, other beings, memory, and unrealized futures.

Generative Studies provides the wider framework.

Generative Topological Ontology functions as its foundational ontology.

The argument connects Self-Externalization, Interface Ontology, Pre-Humanity, Self-Precedence, Language Derivatives, Soku, Za, Seki, Position, Namelessness, and Workhood through the problem of Co-Being.

Contemporary screens provide immediate access to distant wars, disasters, deaths, ordinary lives, and celebrations.

Human beings possess more information about distant events than before.

This does not necessarily increase Co-Being.

Knowing is not identical with being-with.

Seeing an image does not establish Co-Being by itself.

Understanding an explanation does not establish Co-Being by itself.

Expressing approval or disapproval does not establish Co-Being by itself.

Co-Being occurs when the existence of another, which cannot be fully assimilated into one's own cognition, can nevertheless alter one's present.

The contemporary crisis is therefore more fundamental than a shortage of empathy.

What can be lost is the ontological condition that allows empathy to emerge.

Different beings remain different while sharing one present.

This condition is called the co-existential present.

Its erosion is the loss of the co-existential present.

Son names persistence through time.

It includes inheritance from the past and the possibility of continuation toward the future.

Persistence does not mean that an identical substance remains unchanged.

Within Generative Studies, what persists is a structure that maintains connectability while undergoing transformation through relation.

Memory, history, habit, names, and institutions can support persistence.

They can also fix an existence within an established image of itself.

Son therefore contains both a Force of inheritance and a possible Force of closure.

Zai names concrete presence here and now.

It is not merely a coordinate.

Zai emerges when a body touches an environment.

It emerges when a body receives the gaze of others.

It emerges when an existence depends upon things.

It emerges when an existence responds to a place.

Zai is the intersection of the vertical axis of Existence and the horizontal axis of Co-Being.

This intersection is not predetermined.

The meaning of the past can change.

Relations with others can change.

Future possibilities can open or close.

Zai therefore moves.

It is a generative Position through which existence becomes Reality-Grounded.

Kyo names relational sharing without erasing Difference.

It does not mean that different existences become identical.

It is not a solidarity added after completed individuals already exist.

Different beings can share a world, a time, a place, or a problem without becoming reducible to one another.

Kyo is not fusion.

It is overlap.

Within this overlap, each existence is altered by the existence of the other.

Co-Being is therefore not the juxtaposition of already completed beings.

It is an event through which each existence is generated by being with others.

The vertical axis of Existence concerns continuity and transformation across past, present, and future.

A person asks who they were.

A person asks who they are.

A person asks who they may become.

Conceptualization, recollection, anticipation, and self-verification organize this vertical movement.

The horizontal axis of Co-Being concerns with whom, where, and with what one exists.

It includes other people.

It includes nature.

It includes animals.

It includes objects.

It includes technologies.

It includes language.

It includes places.

It includes the dead.

It includes those who have not yet been born.

Sensibility receives the fact that one is touched by these relations before they are fully understood.

Existence therefore corresponds to thought.

Co-Being corresponds to sensibility.

This correspondence is not dualistic.

Thought without sensibility contracts into abstraction without Reality-Grounding.

Sensibility without thought loses the capacity to inherit experience, articulate Difference, and transmit it toward the future.

Sensibility opens existence horizontally.

Thought carries Co-Being vertically through time.

The intersection is the present.

The present is not merely an infinitesimal instant.

It is an Interface.

What has been inherited from the past enters it.

What arrives from beyond the self enters it.

What remains unrealized in the future also enters it.

The present is not the newest information.

It is the Place from which one can respond now to what is other than oneself.

Coexistence and Co-Being must therefore be distinguished.

Coexistence can describe already constituted beings occupying the same environment.

In that model, individuals exist first and relations follow.

Co-Being is more fundamental.

Relation precedes completed being.

A self does not first exist alone and later connect with others.

It becomes articulated as a self through relations with others, nature, language, culture, and place.

This follows the relational priority of Generative Topological Ontology.

Existence is not a closed substance.

It is an open topology of connectability.

Self and other are not completely separated before relation.

Their boundaries emerge within relation.

Both are transformed as those boundaries move.

Co-Being therefore concerns the originary plurality of existential generation.

Science is not rejected by this argument.

Science provides indispensable methods for testing claims about the world.

The problem concerns scientism.

Scientism extends a restricted method into the sole criterion of reality.

Scientific rationality can isolate an object.

It can control conditions.

It can identify local causes and local effects.

These procedures have enormous explanatory and predictive power.

The problem begins when local effectiveness is transformed into a total ontology.

Relations that cannot be measured can then appear less real.

Singular events that cannot be reproduced can appear less real.

Sensations that resist explanation can appear less real.

Cultural inheritances extending across long durations can appear less real.

Generative Studies does not describe distant influence, memory, the dead, or anticipated futures as supernatural causes.

It understands them as nonlocal forms of existential generation mediated by meaning, memory, anticipation, Form, and Interface.

The problem with scientism is not the expansion of understanding.

The problem is the closure of reality around what is already explainable.

This closure can produce Scientistic Intellectual Phase Lock.

Cave imagery, religious architecture, ritual, and prayer cannot be reduced to modern aesthetic contemplation.

Lascaux cannot be reduced to one theory of magical or ritual function.

Its darkness, bodily movement, animal figures, sound, and fire can nevertheless be considered as a relational field unlike ordinary space.

The image may have functioned as more than a copy of an object.

It may have mediated relations involving humans, animals, life, death, memory, and anticipation.

Ecclesiastical environments also involve more than decoration.

Murals, sculpture, icons, stained glass, light, acoustics, fragrance, and prayer can generate embodied relations involving earth and heaven, living and dead, individual and community, visible and invisible.

Communication here does not mean only accurate information transfer.

Something not directly present can act on the present through image, trace, object, sound, or place.

The other side of this communication need not be a distant living person.

It can involve the dead.

It can involve ancestors.

It can involve nature.

It can involve a future other.

It can involve something not yet named.

Art does not make the invisible completely visible.

If it did, the invisible would be absorbed into visible information.

Art instead opens a Seki.

What remains invisible can act upon the present while remaining invisible.

What remains incomprehensible can act while remaining incomprehensible.

Visibility itself depends upon invisible conditions.

Seeing depends upon body, distance, light, memory, expectation, and the gaze of others.

Visibility is therefore relational.

The comprehensible also emerges beside what remains incomprehensible.

If everything were completely understood, new questions would no longer emerge.

Incomprehensibility is not merely a defect of knowledge.

It allows the other to remain irreducible to the self.

Understanding in Generative Studies does not eliminate the unknown.

It changes one's Position while sustaining relation with what cannot be fully understood.

Empathy does not require the possession of an identical feeling.

The claim of complete understanding can absorb another's singularity into the self.

A more fundamental condition of empathy is to recognize that an incomprehensible other exists now in the same world.

That existence can alter one's present.

Co-Sensibility describes this capacity.

It is distinct from neurological synesthesia.

Vision, hearing, touch, memory, affect, and thought remain open to one another.

Through this openness, a self senses that it shares a present with what is other than itself.

Human beings have not lost their sensory organs.

They can lose connectability among senses.

They can also lose the capacity of sensibility to open the self toward what is other.

A screen can display an image without transmitting the temperature, smell, duration, or bodily danger of its place.

A statistic can be understood without sensing the singular lives contained within it.

The senses remain active.

They cease to generate Co-Being.

This condition is Sensory Phase Lock.

Intellectual Phase Lock limits thought to an established rational framework.

Sensory Phase Lock limits sensibility to established forms of recognition.

The two reinforce one another.

What cannot be sensed does not easily become an object of thought.

What cannot be thought can be excluded from sensibility as if it were unreal.

The boundary of recognition can then be mistaken for the boundary of reality.

When the horizontal axis of Co-Being is lost, the vertical axis of individual existence appears to remain alone.

A person manages history, qualifications, abilities, achievements, evaluations, and future plans.

The self continually attempts to prove itself from within itself.

This may appear to strengthen individuality.

Yet a vertical axis without a horizontal intersection cannot determine its own Position.

A person may possess extensive information about the self and still lose the feeling that the self is real.

Disbelief in one's own existence is therefore not only a psychological problem.

It can emerge from an ontological structure that attempts to complete self-verification within the self alone.

The self cannot verify itself solely through itself.

The feeling of existing is generated through being touched by what is other than the self.

It is generated through responding.

It is generated through experiencing how that response changes the configuration of a world.

Self-Externalization describes the movement through which a self appears beyond itself through language, works, institutions, technologies, and actions.

External projection alone does not establish Co-Being.

If the exterior becomes occupied by representations of the self, the other is reduced to an extension of that self.

At the limit of Self-Externalization, Pre-Humanity and Self-Precedence become important.

Pre-Humanity indicates that singular-concrete relations involving life, body, and environment precede the abstraction of the human in general.

Self-Precedence indicates that contact and response with what is other than the self precede an established self-identity and participate in generating it.

Co-Being is the form through which these modes of precedence operate in the present.

The self does not approach another as a fully completed self.

It becomes itself anew through contact with another.

Co-Being is therefore not the negation of selfhood.

It releases the self from closed identity and makes singularity more concrete.

The space of Language Derivatives creates another problem.

Language does not merely describe an already completed reality.

Unrealized meanings, future evaluations, and anticipated reactions can be folded back into present action.

Events can become headlines before they are fully experienced.

They can become indicators.

They can become predictions.

They can become narratives.

They can become evaluations.

Connections across distance can multiply without increasing Co-Being.

A distant event can become a sign used to display one's own Position rather than the reality of another requiring a response.

The future can become an object of prediction and management.

The present then ceases to function as Zai.

It becomes a continuously updated display surface.

There can be recency without presentness.

There can be communication without Co-Being.

This is the Lost Present.

Co-Being can be further described through Soku, Za, Seki, and Position.

Soku is the occasion in which different terms enter relation without losing Difference.

A new topology emerges through that relation.

Za is the disposition that makes relation possible.

It does not determine content in advance.

It opens a field in which different existences can arrive, take Position, and generate relations.

Seki is the singular-concrete receptivity within Za.

An Empty Seat is not mere absence.

It is a margin through which a future other, the dead, or what is not yet present can act upon the present.

Position is generated provisionally within relation.

It is not a fixed hierarchy.

It is the point at which vertical and horizontal axes intersect and become Reality-Grounded.

Zai is generated as Position.

Position changes as relations change.

The co-existential present is therefore connected through Soku.

It is opened through Za.

It is receptive through Seki.

It is Reality-Grounded as Position.

Namelessness and Workhood extend this structure into cultural generation.

Not every relation constituting Co-Being can be attributed to one determinate subject.

Culture, language, ritual, and place are generated through countless named and unnamed actions.

A practice can support the present even when its first author cannot be identified.

Namelessness is not the absence of an author.

It is not the erasure of names.

It is the mode through which existential generation is inherited beyond individual attribution.

Workhood is the capacity of a made thing to continue generating relations beyond the intention and ownership of its maker.

A work is not simply a completed object expressing an author.

It leaves a Seki at which another existence can arrive and respond differently.

As long as this Seki remains open, the work functions as a co-existential Interface.

Art does not seek to restore a nostalgic unified worldview.

It does not reproduce magic or religion unchanged.

Premodern communities also contained violence and exclusion.

Community itself cannot be treated as an unconditional good.

What art regenerates is connectability.

Different beings can share a present without losing Difference.

Graffiti can act upon an urban present through a trace after the writer's body has left.

Web Installation can connect distant viewers, screens, communication infrastructures, and physical places.

Its existence is generated anew with each access.

Sayama Aesthetics School does not separate everyday life, lodging, education, making, locality, and visitors.

As a reality display, it repeatedly generates the boundary of here and elsewhere.

These practices do not complete Self-Expression.

They create occasions for Co-Being.

Art does not explain Co-Being to an isolated self.

Through body, place, trace, interval, and time, it composes conditions through which one may sense that what is other than oneself exists here now.

Art is therefore an Interface through which isolated existence can remember Co-Being.

Remembering does not mean returning to an earlier state.

It means generating again in the present a relational possibility that had been lost.

Existence generates the self vertically.

Co-Being generates a world horizontally.

Zai is not a fixed intersection.

It is a topological Interface generated anew through relation.

Co-Being is not a social condition added after existence.

Each existence is generated by being with others.

Empathy is not the possession of the same feeling.

It is the capacity for one's present to be moved by another existence that cannot be fully comprehended.

Co-Sensibility is not the confusion of senses.

It is a co-existential sensibility in which multiple senses and multiple existences appear in one present without losing Difference.

Art does not make the invisible completely visible.

It opens a Seki through which the invisible can act upon the present while remaining invisible.

What is being lost is not information about others.

What is being lost is the present in which the other exists now together with us.

What art generates is not the image of an isolated self.

It generates the present in which a self first appears as itself by existing with what is other than itself.

The complete text is available as a PDF below.

Keywords

Generative Studies; Generative Topological Ontology; Co-Being; Existence; Son; Zai; Kyo; Co-Sensibility; Co-Existential Present; Sensory Phase Lock; Intellectual Phase Lock; Nonlocality; Interface Art; Scientism; Present; Lost Present; Self-Externalization; Pre-Humanity; Self-Precedence; Soku; Za; Seki; Position; Namelessness; Workhood; Reality-Grounding