Research Monograph

A Generative Theory of Co-Being and Iroke

共存在と色気の生成論

Interfaces of Trust and Awareness through Walls, Screens, Fetish, and Mandala

Author
bigakusha-haha / Tomokazu Tanaka
Year
2026
Version
1.0
Status
Ongoing Research
Type
Research Monograph
Last Updated
July 2026
Affiliation
Sayama Aesthetics School / Institute of Aesthetics
Suggested Citation

Tanaka, Tomokazu (bigakusha-haha). 2026. A Generative Theory of Co-Being and Iroke: Interfaces of Trust and Awareness through Walls, Screens, Fetish, and Mandala. Research Monograph Series, Version 1.0. Sayama Aesthetics School / Institute of Aesthetics.

Abstract / Overview

This study develops a Generative Theory of Co-Being and Iroke within Generative Studies and Generative Topological Ontology.

It examines four existential modes.

The first is what is, is.

The second is what is not, is not.

The third is what is not, is.

The fourth is what is, is not.

The first two modes are necessary for local identification.

They distinguish what is present from what is absent.

The problem begins when this binary closure becomes the whole structure of reality.

Relations involving absence, distance, memory, futurity, and invisible others can then disappear from the present.

The co-existential present emerges through the overlap of what is not, is and what is, is not.

Something physically absent may still act relationally in the present.

Something physically or institutionally present may fail to appear as lived existence.

The wall of a room provides a minimal model.

A wall hides what lies beyond it.

Yet what lies beyond the wall continues to exist.

The wall separates and connects at the same time.

A digital screen produces an inverse structure.

Bank balances, photographs, videos, news, and ratings appear visibly on the screen.

They can acquire strong certainty.

Yet they are mediated displays generated through technical, institutional, and social relations.

The screen can therefore conceal the relations that produced what it displays.

This study distinguishes trust from credit or confidence.

Credit depends on records, numbers, proof, institutions, and reproducibility.

Trust accepts relation with another or with a world that can never be completely verified.

The contemporary problem appears when credit in screens, numbers, and systems replaces trust in invisible reality and in one's own sensing.

This displacement contributes to the loss of the co-existential present.

The study interprets fetishization as the localization of a nonlocal relational Force within a discrete object.

Localization itself is not the problem.

Human beings require local bodies, objects, images, names, and numbers in order to act.

The problem begins when the act of localization is forgotten.

A relational Force is then treated as if it belonged inherently to the object.

A closed fetish encloses relations within the object.

A generative fetish uses a local object to reopen relations toward bodies, places, times, and others that cannot be reduced to it.

The first tends toward idolization.

The second tends toward the Mark and the Interface.

Workhood is also understood relationally.

It is not an attraction owned by a completed artwork.

Workhood is generated through relations involving work, body, place, time, memory, and absence.

When this relational attraction draws the body prior to explanation and produces awareness of oneself as already drawn, it appears as Iroke.

Iroke does not mean sexual content.

It names a sensible generative Force that cannot be fully localized within an object.

Iroke emerges through the overlap of presence and absence.

It emerges through nearness and inaccessibility.

It emerges through what is visible and what remains invisible.

Beauty may be evaluated as the Form of an object.

Iroke is generated within the relation involving self and non-self.

The viewer does not discover a hidden answer inside the work.

The viewer can instead become aware that the body had already responded before an explanation was available.

The work does not transmit awareness as information.

It leaves an Empty Seat in which awareness may occur.

The study also examines Shingon mandala and Ajikan as Interfaces.

This comparison does not reduce Shingon Buddhism to Generative Studies.

It does not claim doctrinal identity.

The comparison concerns a relational structure involving a localized Mark, embodied practice, an invisible whole, and transformation of the participant.

A mandala is not simply a representation of a complete world.

It can function as a practical configuration through which the participant reorganizes relation with the world.

Ajikan also places a localized Mark within a relation involving body, breath, vision, voice, place, and lineage.

The local Mark does not contain the whole.

It provides an entrance into a nonlocal relational whole.

The distinction involving fetish, idol, and Interface is therefore not determined by Form alone.

The decisive question is whether localization closes relation or reopens it.

Art in the practice of bigakusha-haha is understood as the creation of an occasion for awareness.

The work does not give an answer.

It reveals the phase of the self that demanded an answer.

Sayama Aesthetics School functions as long-duration Interface Art.

Lodging, everyday life, research, artwork, walls, rooms, conversations, silence, and time remain distinct while forming relational configurations.

These relations generate Za and Seki through which invisible others may be sensed as co-present.

Workhood emerges when relations previously excluded from the present appear through an Empty Seat.

Iroke is the Force through which the Empty Seat draws the body.

Awareness is the event through which the self discovers that it had already been drawn.

Generative Studies therefore does not seek the recovery of a lost past sensibility.

Generation is irreversible.

The task is regeneration.

A screen can also become an Interface when it makes its own boundary and exterior perceptible.

A Mark localizes a relation.

Soku brings the body into contact with the Mark.

Position is generated.

The Non- reopens that Position toward what lies outside it.

Through this circulation, trust in sensing can be regenerated.

Art does not convert the invisible into a visible object.

It opens a Seki in which one may sense that the invisible acts in the present while remaining invisible.

It creates an occasion through which one may begin to trust that sensing again.

Full Text

This research monograph develops a Generative Theory of Co-Being and Iroke.

It begins with four existential modes.

The first is what is, is.

The second is what is not, is not.

The third is what is not, is.

The fourth is what is, is not.

The first mode affirms what is present.

The second excludes what is absent.

These two modes are necessary for local identification and causal determination.

The problem begins when they are treated as the complete structure of reality.

Invisible relations can then disappear.

Latent possibilities can disappear.

The efficacy of absence can disappear.

The third mode describes something that is physically absent but still acts relationally in the present.

A person beyond a wall can belong to this mode.

A memory of the dead can belong to this mode.

An anticipated future can belong to this mode.

A bodily trace retained by an Empty Seat can belong to this mode.

The fourth mode describes something that is physically or institutionally present but does not appear as lived and responsive existence.

A person may remain registered within institutions.

A person may remain connected to information networks.

Yet the person may no longer experience the world as responsive.

The actual present is therefore not produced only by the first two modes.

It is also generated through the overlap of the third and fourth modes.

This overlap is called the co-existential present.

The relation also expresses the operation of the Non-.

The Non- is not simple rejection.

It reopens identity toward its outside.

It allows different phases to overlap without eliminating Difference.

The wall of a room provides a minimal model of locality and nonlocality.

The wall distinguishes an inside from an outside.

It produces a local here.

Yet persons, buildings, roads, air, and forms of life continue beyond it.

The fact that they are unseen does not mean that they do not exist.

The wall is therefore both obstruction and Interface.

Sound can cross it.

Light can cross it.

Temperature can cross it.

Vibration can cross it.

Communication can cross it.

The wall connects by separating here from elsewhere.

Co-Being does not abolish the wall.

It is the sensible assurance that what remains unseen beyond the wall still participates in the same present.

The digital screen creates a reverse configuration.

Bank balances appear on it.

Photographs appear on it.

Videos appear on it.

News appears on it.

Ratings appear on it.

These displays are not reality itself.

They are generated through selection, calculation, capture, editing, institutions, records, and networks.

Yet visible displays can acquire more certainty than invisible realities.

What actually exists beyond the wall can become difficult to trust.

What cannot be touched but appears on a screen can become easier to trust.

This study distinguishes trust from credit or confidence.

Credit depends upon records, numbers, proof, institutions, and reproducibility.

Trust accepts relation with an other or with a world that can never be completely verified.

Sensing is also more than mood.

It is the reception of an efficacy coming from what is other than the self before that efficacy has been fully represented or proven.

Trust in sensing means accepting this efficacy as a real connection even when complete proof is unavailable.

Contemporary scientism and digitally evaluated environments expand measurable credit.

They can also weaken pre-measurable trust.

Trust in persons and places can decline.

Credit in screens, numbers, and systems can substitute for a sense of reality.

This displacement contributes to the loss of the co-existential present.

If the unseen other cannot be sensed, trust weakens.

If what is sensed cannot be trusted, sensibility itself weakens.

The wall can then cease to be a boundary that connects by separating.

It becomes an absolute rupture.

Human beings cannot simply return to a pre-screen sensibility.

Generation is irreversible.

The impossibility of restoring a past sensibility does not mean that the capacity to sense cannot be regenerated.

Awareness of substitution can itself become an occasion for topological transformation.

A screen display is not reality itself.

It is one connection to reality.

An unseen other is not therefore nonexistent.

Becoming aware of this distinction can transform one's mode of connection to the world.

This question leads to Workhood and Iroke.

In the artistic practice of bigakusha-haha, a work is not an object that contains completed meaning.

It is an occasion through which viewers may become aware of the boundary of their own perception.

It is also an occasion through which a body may become aware that it had already been responding to the world.

Workhood is therefore not an attribute owned by a completed object.

It is a relational structure.

Work can connect with viewer.

Work can connect with place.

Work can connect with time.

Work can connect with memory.

Work can connect with absence.

A topological transition can then occur.

Workhood is sexual only in a structural sense.

This does not mean sexual representation.

It does not reduce art to libido.

Sexual attraction often occurs before analytical explanation.

A person can first be drawn.

Reasons can be constructed later.

Attraction is also not localized only in another body.

It can emerge through distance.

It can emerge through voice.

It can emerge through atmosphere.

It can emerge through time.

It can emerge through memory.

It can emerge through the unknown.

It can emerge through prohibition.

It can emerge through expectation.

Workhood likewise operates as an attraction that cannot be fully localized in its object.

This attraction is called Iroke.

Iroke does not arise from complete formal presence.

It emerges through what is visible and what is not visible.

It emerges through nearness and inaccessibility.

It emerges through presence and absence.

Beauty may be evaluated as a Form of an object.

Iroke is generated within relation involving self and non-self.

Iroke is the sensible Force through which what is not, is and what is, is not intersect within the body.

The viewer therefore does not primarily discover a hidden answer inside the work.

The viewer may discover that the body had already been drawn before an explanation was available.

The viewer may discover that the non-self had already been acting upon the self.

The work does not transmit awareness as information.

It leaves an Empty Seat in which awareness may occur.

Understanding does not have to occur immediately.

A later pause before a bank balance can belong to Workhood.

A sudden awareness of life beyond a wall can belong to Workhood.

The temporality of the work can therefore exceed the moment of viewing.

Nonlocal relations are difficult to own directly.

They are difficult to compare directly.

They are difficult to preserve directly.

They are difficult to exchange directly.

Human beings therefore localize relational Forces within objects, images, bodies, names, and numbers.

Localization is necessary.

It compresses a complex world into an actionable Form.

The problem is not localization.

The problem is forgetting that localization has occurred.

Fetishization appears when a Force generated through relations is received as a Force inherently owned by an object.

This structure can occur in money.

It can occur in artistic value.

It can occur in brands.

It can occur in sexual images.

It can occur in ratings.

It can occur in authority.

It can occur in screen visibility.

A fetish does not have to be rejected in every case.

The absence of a body can become condensed within a fragment.

Time can become condensed within a Mark.

A lost relation can then become sensible again.

This makes it possible to distinguish closed fetish from generative fetish.

Closed fetish encloses Force within the object.

It causes the relations behind the object to be forgotten.

Generative fetish uses a local object to reopen relations toward bodies, times, places, and others that cannot be reduced to it.

Closed fetish tends toward idolization.

Generative fetish tends toward the Mark and the Interface.

An idol is not defined simply by the existence of an image.

An idol emerges when an image is treated as the final location of Force.

A Mark opens what lies beyond through the object.

An idol encloses what lies beyond within the object.

A numerical display can remain an Interface when it opens further relations.

It becomes idol-like when it substitutes for the whole of reality.

The same issue appears in mandala and Ajikan.

This study does not reduce Shingon Buddhism to Generative Studies.

It does not claim doctrinal identity.

The comparison concerns a structure.

A localized Mark is involved.

Embodied practice is involved.

An invisible whole is involved.

Transformation of the participant is involved.

A Shingon mandala is not merely a religious picture.

It can actualize a relational order through visual and ritual configuration.

The participant does not simply observe a copy of the world.

The participant can reorganize relation with the world through the configuration.

Ajikan also involves a localized Mark.

The moon disc is involved.

The lotus is involved.

The Siddham A is involved.

Posture is involved.

Breath is involved.

Vision is involved.

Voice is involved.

Awareness is involved.

The localized body becomes connected with a wider relational whole.

The local Mark does not contain that whole.

It becomes an entrance through which the participant can enter relation with it.

Ajikan can therefore be understood as an Interface.

The practitioner does not remain an unchanged observer outside the Mark.

The practitioner enters relation involving Mark, body, breath, place, and lineage.

The phase of being can change through this contact.

No religious image is automatically an idol.

No mandala is automatically free from fetishization.

A mandala can become fetishized through ownership, authority, or rarity.

A single image can function as an Interface when practice opens relation beyond it.

The decisive issue is not Form alone.

The decisive issue is whether localization closes or reopens.

The artistic practice of bigakusha-haha places awareness at the center of the work.

Awareness is not informational content delivered by the work.

It is an event.

A viewer becomes aware of how perception has been arranged.

A viewer becomes aware of how trust has been arranged.

The viewer may begin to change relation with the world.

Art does not give a completed answer.

It reveals the phase of the self that demanded one.

This account of the work can be difficult to accommodate within an art system centered on visible objects, authorial intention, explainable meaning, market value, and measurable effects.

Yet lack of understanding cannot be treated as proof that the work is correct.

That would make the theory closed and unfalsifiable.

The task of the work is not to exclude those who no longer sense.

It is to introduce a minimal Difference.

It is to introduce interval.

It is to introduce a possibility of response into the condition of not sensing.

Sayama Aesthetics School functions as long-duration Interface Art.

It does not collapse lodging, domestic life, research, and artwork into one identity.

It keeps their boundaries mobile.

The boundary involving here and elsewhere remains mobile.

The boundary involving guest and inhabitant remains mobile.

The boundary involving daily life and art remains mobile.

The boundary involving interior and exterior remains mobile.

Walls are not neutral backgrounds.

Rooms are not neutral containers.

Stays are not neutral events.

Conversations, silences, and time participate in the work.

Together they form Za and Seki.

Through them, invisible others may be sensed as co-present.

The work is not a completed object of what is, is.

Workhood emerges when relations previously excluded from the present become perceptible through an apparently Empty Seat.

Iroke is the Force through which that Empty Seat draws the body.

Awareness is the event in which the self discovers itself as already drawn.

The task is therefore regeneration rather than recovery.

Contemporary persons cannot return to a past community.

They cannot return to a pre-screen sensibility.

Discarding screens would not solve the problem.

A screen can also become an Interface when it makes its own boundary and exterior perceptible.

Locality must not be rejected.

Without local bodies, objects, images, and numbers, nonlocal relations cannot become Reality-Grounded.

At the same time, localizations cannot be treated as final substances.

When they are treated as final, relations close within idols.

Generative Studies therefore calls for circulation.

A Mark localizes a relation.

Soku brings a body into contact with the Mark.

A Position is generated.

The Non- reopens that Position toward its outside.

This circulation regenerates trust in sensing.

The same feeling cannot simply be recovered.

Yet awareness of that irretrievability can become an occasion for a new response.

A body that knows screens can respond again to what lies beyond walls.

It can respond again to others.

It can respond again to absence.

It can respond again to the future.

The co-existential present is generated through the overlap of what is not, is and what is, is not.

The physical wall conceals what lies beyond while preserving its reality.

The digital screen displays what lies beyond while concealing its own exterior.

When this Difference is forgotten, trust can be replaced by credit.

Relation can be replaced by display.

The world can be replaced by the screen.

Fetish and idol arise when the Force of nonlocal relations is attributed to a local object and the act of localization is forgotten.

Mandala, Ajikan, the work, and Sayama Aesthetics School can instead be understood as Interfaces that preserve localized Forms while opening them toward nonlocal relations.

Workhood is not the charm possessed by an object.

It is the Iroke generated through this connection.

Iroke is a sensible generative Force.

It draws the body prior to explanation.

It allows the self to become aware that it had already been responding to the world.

The art of bigakusha-haha does not represent a lost sensibility.

It does not restore a past sensibility.

It designs occasions that generate awareness of lost sensibility and reconfigure trust in sensing.

Art does not convert the invisible into a visible object.

It opens a Seki in which one can sense that the invisible acts in the present while remaining invisible.

It also creates an occasion through which one may begin to trust that sensing again.

The complete text is available as a PDF below.

Keywords

Generative Studies; Generative Topological Ontology; Co-Being; Co-Existential Present; Iroke; Workhood; Interface; Trust; Credit; Confidence; Trust in Sensing; Wall; Digital Screen; Fetish; Generative Fetish; Closed Fetish; Idol; Mandala; Ajikan; Awareness; Generative Occasion; Empty Seat; Soku; Za; Seki; Position; the Non-; Nonlocality; Reality-Grounding; Sayama Aesthetics School